Find The Best Rate Hassle-Free
It’s Nice to Meet You!
At the 1st Choice Agency, I take our name seriously: I want to be your 1st choice for all things insurance. I have a wide variety of carriers to choose from and my goal is to remove the hassle of finding the best coverage at the best rate for you. Oh, and did I mention that I service all of New York and Pennsylvania?
I believe that finding an agent who sees you as more than just a number on a spreadsheet is so important. That is why I started 1st Choice Agency. I want to get to know you so I can find a solution that truly works for your needs. So let’s get to know one another and get to work finding you the best coverage at the best rate. Contact me today for a personalized, comprehensive insurance experience.
Principle Agent / Owner
Rob Teeter
Here what our clients have to say
Ryan Tinna
13:52 18 Aug 23
My experience with Robert from first choice agency has been very easy and was amazing. They helped my cut my insurance cost in half and where tentative and very helpful with any and all questions I had. 100% Recommend them !!
lacey martin
20:41 15 Aug 23
10/10 recommend robert sheldon for all the help you may need on insurance. he was able to help me in very little time and got me the cheapest rates i’ve seen for myself.
Laura Ingalls
12:04 05 Jul 23
They have been great to work with. They were available to answer questions that I had. It was nice to work with. I would recommend them to my family and friends.
Holly My Little House Happy Heart
00:51 04 May 23
Rob is great to work with. He has access to multiple insurance companies and was able to save me over a thousand dollars on my car insurance! Professional and timely.
Jeff Johnson
13:47 30 Apr 23
Rob is just an absolutely awesome guy! And is willing to do whatever it takes to get you the best deal possible. My 20 year old daughter is buying her first brand new car. She got a quote from her current insurance company for $400 dollars per month and I almost fell over. I contacted Rob to see if we could get that lower. After Rob took the time to contact cooperate because my daughter is buying a 2024 model year. And having them upload that model year in the system because it’s too early for those rates to be available. Rob was able to get my daughters quote to $140 per month! Rob saved my daughter $260 per month!! And quickly too! This man will do everything in his power to get you the best rate possible!!! My opinion 5 stars isn’t enough! Thank you again Rob! We look forward to many years of you as our agent!
Brandi Teeter
21:06 27 Apr 23
Rob will shop around and make sure your getting the best price for what you need. He makes it easy for the process. Also he will keep shopping down the road to see if he can better you a better price again in the future. He never settles.
Erica Harty
15:09 27 Apr 23
Rob has saved me SO much money and time! Anything I need he answers me quickly and deals with all my questions! Definitely recommend and have recommended so many family and friends to him that are all also so happy with him! Thanks Rob!
FILLY PHAN
13:36 25 Apr 23
Extremely knowledgeable and professional. Rob went above an beyond to secure the absolute best rate possible. No bs, no upsetting, just hooked me up with a great price right off the bat. Call an just see what Rob can save you.
arianna westover
15:23 12 Apr 23
Found me the best insurance rate than anyone else i had talked to. definitely recommend this place for your insurance needs!
Christine Snyder
20:15 24 Feb 23
Was very helpful combining home insurance and auto policySaved me more than one thousand dollars and made the process seamlessHandled everything via text and emailWas patient and worked with meGreat job!! Thankful and grateful
Bridget
20:59 03 Feb 23
Rob was wonderfully pleasant, prompt and efficient with his service. He saved me big on both homeowners and car insurance! I would highly reccomend!!!
Jessica VanEtten
13:03 05 Jan 23
Robert was very helpful in getting me lower rates then what I was paying! Looking forward to doing business with 1st choice agency
Caitlin Caltagirone
17:04 10 Nov 22
I had a great experience with Rob Teeter from 1st choice agency. He was very responsive and knowledgeable about what all comes with homeowners insurance. Would highly recommend.
Bryan Zheng
19:46 04 Nov 22
Robert has been extremely helpful finding the right insurances for my business. He was very professional and responded to all of my questions quickly. Thank you!
Ashley Andrus
19:42 03 Nov 22
Rob Teeter was amazing. He went above and beyond to help me with my vehicle insurance and registration. If I could I'd give him more than 5 stars!
nate wetzelberg
17:18 19 Jul 22
I had a very pleasant experience overall using 1st Choice Agency, LLC. Rob was extremely personal and professional, and did everything in a timely manner. I will be referring friends and family his way for any insurance needs.
Sharron Stillman
17:38 24 May 22
Best decision I made in 2022 was researching insurance coverage and agents. Aside from money saved which is a huge plus.. but the customer service has been too notch. Response time to questions, policy changes and everything life has thrown at me has been practically instant! Professional yet personable each and everytime.
Tanya Rought
15:45 09 May 22
Rob teeter was very friendly and very helpful. This is our first time getting homeowners insurance and he answered every question we had. Great service and assistance 👍 Recommend giving him a call.
NeverAgainz
02:04 07 May 22
Don't be fooled by my name, I would ALWAYS choose Rob as an Agent, over all. Never have I had someone that legit looked out for me, my family and my satisfaction, more than he has. Top notch, one hell of a guy right here.-B. Causer
Barb Goble
00:03 05 May 22
I've been with Rob and his agency for quite some time now with a few different vehicles. He always saves me money, very professional, works fast and accurate. Always available to answer any questions I have. Best I've ever dealt with. He knows what people want and he delivers.
Brian Monk
16:56 23 Apr 22
Amazing service and professionalism. Helped me on a Saturday . Not a salesman but a partner. Highly recommend to anyone on need of help
Kelly S
00:02 25 Mar 22
I appreciate Rob always being ready to help with no fuss. A quick call or a text and he is right there ready to help in any way he can. He also beat every quote we had gotten... it was a was win/win for us!
Katie Murphy
01:47 22 Mar 22
Rob has bent over backwards fixing a mistake I had made and went above and beyond calling different places and filling paperwork for me in in timely fashion. I would recommend him to my friends and family. You are in great hands!
Tandi Murphy
15:49 21 Mar 22
Rob is very attentive and is quick to respond with questions. I would highly recommend this insurance agency. I have been with them for a few years now and have no regrets about it!
Jacob Welch
01:47 17 Mar 22
One of the best insurance brokers in the area. They helped me insure my first home, as well as bundle with my auto and save a lot of money. Highly recommend rob at 1st choice!!
Tabetha Kelsey (HoldinMyOwn)
18:00 08 Mar 22
Rob is definitely the "above and beyond" agent. I honestly thought I was going to have to sacrifice either my food delivery or my rideshare because I couldn't find an insurance company that would cover both. Not only did Rob spend days combing through companies to find someone to cover me, but he found me an affordable rate within my budget. He has also found savings for the people I have referred to him. He was patient in answering questions to be sure I understood my coverage, supplying all the necessary documentation, graphs, charts. I highly recommend him for your insurance needs.
Tara Mehnert
13:30 06 Feb 22
Highly recommend. Even after having one issue after another Rob was very patient and very professional with me. He took the time to find me better rates and answered any questions I had. I will send him more customers his way. Thanks Rob
Ryan M.
21:20 25 Jan 22
Rob Teeter was able to save us considerably compared to our current insurance company, with very good coverages in auto, homeowners, and an umbrella policy.
Roxanne Schneider
09:16 16 Dec 21
1st Choice is highly recommended!Refreshing and professional in every regard!Rob provides exceptional service, attention to your personal situation and ongoing professional advice. It is a pleasure to support this small business.
Mike Mcdaniel
21:53 15 Dec 21
This guy runs an amazing business is a great person and if you need insurance he's somebody you should go through
Doug Batterson
14:53 30 Oct 21
Very pleasant experience, very knowledgeable on my questions, quick and easy , 5 star rating
Review Us
1st Choice Agency is a proud member of SIAA, the #1 agency partner in the US that is committed to the creation, retention, and growth of independent insurance agencies.
$B
Premiums Written
+
Members